European educators know the termÌý.ÌýIt is not really a word in the English language, but isÌýmuch used in Europe.
Yet a Scotsman, Professor Bob Stradling, coined it.ÌýIt was an approach that helped to moveÌýpost-war war nations and their history curricula out of extreme nationalism, towards exploring a wider world view.ÌýLooking beyond one’s country is important not only for history curricula, however, but also for wider educational improvement.
Care must be taken: this cannot become the uncontextualised copying warned about in Lucy Crehan’sÌýCleverlands. Yet, the recent Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) assessment debacleÌý-Ìýreplicated in other parts of the UK -Ìýresulted inÌýgovernment ministers fall back on “we’re doing it because they are justifications.
SQA results: The ‘exams debacle’ without exams
SQA controversy:Ìý‘We need a system we’re all confident in’
SQA results U-turn:Ìý‘I am dreading the next few weeks’
Are exams still fit for purpose?Ìý‘The SQA results debacle reveals deeper weaknesses’
Analysis:ÌýSQA exam system ‘has largelyÌýmaintainedÌýthe status quo’
A more nuanced multiperspectivity may help, though:Ìýevery now and then an idea comes from afar that is worth exploring.
When I was the president of the Scottish Association of History Teachers,Ìýwe promoted multiperspectivity in the curriculum but also in our professional learning. At each annual conference, I tried to invite an international speaker.ÌýOne of theÌýmost memorableÌýwas Benny, a school leader from Denmark. In Scottish public policy, of course, there haveÌýbeen many wishful gazes towards Scandinavia.
In a packed University of Edinburgh lecture hall,ÌýBenny took the stage.ÌýHis presentation style was very different.ÌýIt took a while for the audience to catch on.ÌýAfter introductions, Benny put up the first slide and stood in silence.ÌýIt was an awkward silence for all. And then he explained:Ìýhe was not going to read through slides, because what would be the point in that?
His approach was to put a slideÌýup, let the audience read and discussÌýit, and then he would lead more discussion and questions.ÌýIt was aÌý“flippedâ€� approach, which tells us something about pedagogies, access to information and learning and hierarchies (or lack of them); the onus is on the learner with teachers facilitating.
Benny gave a fascinating insight into Danish education, using this approach.ÌýThen he got to a section on Danish assessment -Ìýand he almost sparked a teachers’ revolution that day.
Benny told us that students are given a task and time to go away and complete it, perhaps over 24 to 36 hours. Students then come back to the school and lead discussions on their work to a teacher panel. If it meets pre-shared criteria, they pass.ÌýIf it veers off track, the student goes away and reworks things before presenting again.Ìý
There was a low-level chatter amongÌýthe Scottish teachers, which built and built and built. Eventually, there was a crescendo of “we want thatâ€�, “how good is that?â€�ÌýandÌý“that’s the way to assessâ€�.
Then an unconvinced audience member responded:Ìý“But how do you manage it?â€�ÌýBenny responded calmly that Danish teachersÌýorganise rotas for the panels and times for students to come. “But that must take ages,â€�Ìýthe questioner retorted firmly.
Benny reflected, then replied:Ìý“And so does your system -Ìýsending, marking, moderating papers.ÌýYou might think we are mad.ÌýBut you are marking students you don’t know and have never even met -Ìýwhereas we see the students, their progress and achievement against learning outcomes.â€�
Simplicity is perhaps at the root of Scandinavian success. Meanwhile, we tie ourselves in bureaucratic Gordian knots. We can improve by exploring international ideas if, in our own system, permission exists for change and -Ìýindeed -ÌýreformÌýwhen things don’t work.
Will the 2020 SQA crisis lead to a fundamental shift inÌýScottish education?ÌýShort-term political pragmatism has led Scottish education up many cul de sacs, and Benny perhaps thought we were mad -Ìýso let’s prove him wrong.
Neil McLennan is a senior lecturer and director of leadership programmes at the University of Aberdeen, and a former history teacher