The old class divides are gone - here’s how schools should change, too
In the mid-1990s, as Europe’s political leaders heralded a new meritocratic age, two sociologists from the other side of the world declared class was dead.
Australian academics Jan Pakulski and Malcolm Waters claimed that traditional descriptions of class no longer captured how people lived their lives or saw themselves. In their book The Death of Class, they argued that “classes are dissolving�.
This might have remained a niche academic debate were it not for the rapid social changes of the time. Traditional loyalties to political parties were fading. Consumer capitalism was encouraging people from all walks of life to buy into the same brands and technologies. Working-class families took foreign holidays; middle-class professionals watched football games. Work itself was changing: factories and heavy industries were being replaced by the service and knowledge economy. Jobs no longer neatly signalled a person’s class.
At the same time, debates around gender, sexuality, race and ethnicity had moved centre stage. Old class certainties did, for a time, appear to be dissolving.
The only problem with the “death of class� narrative was that it wasn’t true. Socioeconomic background, measured through indicators such as parents’ occupations, income or education, and class more broadly, remains in every society the most consistent predictor of life outcomes from educational results and job prospects to good health, life expectancy and much more besides.
Understanding this matters for anyone with the power to shape opportunity, including those who work in schools.
One of the central arguments that we explore in our new book Cracking the Class Code: how the opportunity game is rigged - and how firms can help fix it is that contemporary class divides are expressed in often subtle and imperceptible ways - ways of acting, speaking and looking - that influence people’s prospects in the top-tier professional firms that straddle the globe. When combined with the right social networks, these markers create a deeply uneven playing field.
The effects of class on education
Across generations, social class has remained one of the strongest predictors of children’s educational outcomes, in a pattern that has barely shifted for more than half a century.
Drawing on one of the richest datasets in the world, tracking tens of thousands of Britons born in four successive generations from 1946 to 1990, University of Oxford sociologists found that class still shapes educational and career prospects across the life-course.
In this study, class was measured through a composite of parents’ occupations and their educational qualifications, which together capture long-term socioeconomic position.
School pupils were grouped into three categories according to their parents’ backgrounds - most advantaged, middle and least advantaged.
Among children with the highest test scores at age 10, those from the most advantaged homes were twice as likely to complete upper-secondary school as equally high-scoring peers from the least advantaged homes.
The influence of class did not stop at the school gates. Tracking two children scoring the same at age 10, the one from a higher-class background was far more likely to move into a professional or managerial job and enjoy greater economic security in adulthood. The academic scores at age 10 explained only about a third of the gap in later educational attainment, and just a fifth of the gap in occupational outcomes.
For one of the authors, Bastian Betthäuser, the study highlighted a universal challenge that all societies continue to face: “Equalising the highly unequal playing field faced by individuals from different social backgrounds.�
There is not a single country in the world where socioeconomic background does not strongly predict children’s academic outcomes. Data from the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development’s (OECD) Programme for International Student Assessment (Pisa) tests, which assess 15-year-olds in reading, maths and science in over 80 countries, show the same recurring pattern: students from more advantaged homes outperform their less advantaged peers, often by the equivalent of several years of schooling.
What’s more, the OECD describes a perfect storm of global megatrends. Rapidly evolving technology is creating well-paid jobs for a few while taking away stable jobs from many others; soaring housing costs in the world’s biggest cities are creating exclusive opportunity zones, pushing out anyone who doesn’t already own a home.
For more and more of us, the problem is no longer outright poverty but unrelenting struggle: long hours, insecure work, rising housing costs and the sense of running hard simply to stay in place, with no clear route to the opportunities promised by the rhetoric we hear about an apparently classless meritocratic society.
Class is very much alive; it has not disappeared so much as changed form, evolving into a powerful mix of economic and cultural capital - less visible, more defended and more consequential.
‘The Detached’ vs the rest
In our view, the defining class divide of our era lies between a “detached� group and everyone else. The Detached are those who have achieved something like escape velocity. They move easily between the world’s major cities to take up work, education or lifestyle opportunities.
This might be called the millionaires’ club, the richest fraction of the population with a disproportionate share of wealth, property and power in society.
The key to being Detached is not income, but wealth that can be mobilised to fund opportunity - like paying for a child’s four-year degree course at an American Ivy League university or funding the five- or six-figure housing deposit needed when they first enter the property market.
There are no absolute cut-offs when it comes to determining who does and doesn’t have mobilisable wealth. In the UK, the wealthiest 1 per cent of households (around half a million of them) had wealth of at least £3 million (around US$4 million) in 2022. In the US, similar wealth levels are held by a much larger proportion - around 5 per cent (6 to 7 million households).
The lion’s share of the Detached is made up of the inheritors - those who have been born into money. Since the 1980s, asset returns have vastly outstripped wage growth, meaning those with pre-existing wealth have largely been able to consolidate their positions, while nearly everyone else has been left behind, save those who have become extremely high earners (a good rule of thumb for this is to think about earnings that are five times the median).
Class has become more complicated - except for the Detached. For this elite group, the traditional class indicators - income, occupation, education level, property ownership, wealth, social connections and cultural habits - align in a way that they used to for most people.
For everyone else, the class picture has become muddier. Traditional definitions of working class and middle class (which themselves vary by country) seem obsolete in countries where a majority work in professional roles but can still struggle to afford the rent or mortgage; where shrewd or lucky older generations of the working classes can own properties valued in the millions of dollars but have a social network where most of their friends own very little; and where two similarly educated young adults with the same job can have vastly different lifestyles thanks to varying inheritances of wealth and parental help.
Working-class and middle-class labels are no longer reliable indicators of societal divides, if indeed they ever were. This is one of the reasons why we propose a new three-way categorisation that describes today’s societies as we understand them.
The three Ds: a new class frameworkÂ
The three Ds are not just a way of describing today’s societies - they also point to the origins from which the next generation will emerge.
The Detached are the advantaged origin classes of the future. Their children will start life with the cushion of inherited property, networks and financial safety nets that will likely sustain their positions in society.
The Disenchanted are the new middle origin class - the squeezed middle, forced to fight ever harder just to stand still, as the cost of family living escalates. For this group, absolute downward mobility looms as a constant threat.
The Dispossessed, meanwhile, are the precarious lower origin classes of the next generation. With little or no wealth to transfer, and often being confined to insecure housing, their children are likely to face the same barriers as their parents.
The balance between the groups differs across nations. In some countries, the Disenchanted will be the majority. In poorer nations, the Dispossessed may make up as much as 70 per cent of populations.
The Disenchanted are the broad but increasingly insecure middle. Once the anchor of stability, they are increasingly a source of disillusion. Older members of the group may have had professional or steady working-class jobs that enabled them to buy their own home, but much of their wealth is tied up in housing. Younger members are more likely to be degree-educated but asset poor, squeezed by stagnant wages and rising housing costs. They feel the opportunities and pay returns shrinking, leaving them anxious that the system no longer works for people like them.
Lifestyles for the younger generation vary increasingly by parental support and inheritance. The lucky receive an early inheritance or can tap into the “bank of mum and dad�, allowing them to jump on the housing ladder early or invest in equivalent assets. The rest are exchanging the better chunk of their monthly pay cheque for an increasingly small metreage of space, with little left over to enjoy the cities they’re paying to be in.
These are global patterns, impacted by declining levels of upward absolute mobility. For a generation raised on the promise that hard work would secure a prosperous life, the reality is a big disappointment: standards of living increasingly depend on family wealth.
The Dispossessed, meanwhile, are those locked out of the system entirely. With little or negative wealth, no stable stake in property and increasingly insecure jobs, their life chances are constrained by the rising cost of basics, especially housing.
Their position is reinforced by structural traps: insecure work prevents saving, rising housing costs block geographic mobility and weak local labour markets limit access to better-paid jobs. The skills and assets this group possess are rarely recognised by mainstream institutions. Often they suffer from “deficit� approaches, seen as lacking rather than being valued for the distinctive strengths they may bring.
They often feel misunderstood by metropolitan elites. The system, they believe, has failed them for generations. Younger generations may have higher education credentials than their forebears, but they remain locked out of success. In urban areas, if they can find work it is often in low-paid jobs, stacking shelves in supermarkets, serving coffee in cafes or working short-term contracts in call centres and warehouses. They face increasingly precarious lives.
How should schools respond?
What does this changing class landscape mean for schools? We see at least three important implications.Â
First, schools need to look beyond traditional measures of disadvantage. Economic insecurity and other disadvantages affect a much wider group of children and families, and free school meal eligibility is an increasingly crude barometer.
Hundreds of schools are now using the South-West Social Mobility Commission’s free to reflect on their equity practices and adopt a more forensic approach to identifying and addressing the multitude of barriers that can limit children’s learning, while maintaining high expectations for every child.Â
Second, the same class codes we document in elite workplaces also operate in classrooms. As sociologist Annette Lareau has shown, middle-class children are often raised through concerted cultivation: speaking up, questioning authority and negotiating for attention. Working-class children are more often encouraged to respect authority, show restraint and avoid “making a fuss�.
Research also shows that teachers can underrate pupils from less advantaged backgrounds, even when test scores are identical. Educators must therefore be alert to how learned behaviours associated with class advantage can be mistaken for innate talent.Â
Third, and most fundamentally, we must confront the broken promise of education. The old bargain that working hard and gaining qualifications will secure a good job and a better life is unravelling for more and more of us.
Stubbornly high levels of school absence should prompt us to question whether our educational offer is sufficiently compelling for the next generation. We need a richer curriculum that values vocational, creative and academic excellence, alongside the human capabilities that will become even more important in an AI-driven world: knowing how to navigate institutions, build networks and negotiate opportunities.Â
Schools can and must do more to widen opportunity. But they cannot repair a broken system alone. We also need to rewire the opportunity system beyond the school gates: creating more secure jobs, affordable housing and fairer rewards for work. Only by combining better education with these wider changes can we create a genuinely level playing field for future generations.
Lee Elliot Major is professor of social mobility at the University of Exeter and Dr Anne-Marie Sim is the co-founder and lead for the South-West Social Mobility Commission (SWSMC). This article is an edited extract of their book Cracking the Class Code: how the opportunity game is rigged - and how firms can help fix it, which is out now
To get essential briefings from ÌÇÐÄVlog magazine delivered directly to your inbox, sign up to our newsletters. And stay up to date with the latest education news via the ÌÇÐÄVlog magazine mobile app - available on  and onÂ
Want to keep reading for free?
Register with ÌÇÐÄVlog and you can read five free articles every month, plus you'll have access to our range of award-winning newsletters.
Register with ÌÇÐÄVlog and you can read five free articles every month, plus you'll have access to our range of award-winning newsletters.
Keep reading for just £4.90 per month
You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £4.90 per month for three months and get:
- Unlimited access to all ÌÇÐÄVlog magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters
You've reached your limit of free articles this month. Subscribe for £4.90 per month for three months and get:
- Unlimited access to all ÌÇÐÄVlog magazine content
- Exclusive subscriber-only stories
- Award-winning email newsletters
topics in this article