Get the best experience in our app
Enjoy offline reading, category favourites, and instant updates - right from your pocket.

Are noise-cancelling headphones harming learning?

Headphone use has exploded, with potentially huge consequences for children’s health and education, warns researcher Dr Aric Sigman

Share

Are noise-cancelling headphones harming learning?

/magazine/teaching-learning/general/are-noise-cancelling-headphones-harming-learning
School children with noise cancelling headphones

Children using noise-cancelling headphones should be considered a public health issue that has serious implications for their learning.

That’s one of the findings of a , a psychologist and lecturer on PSHE education.

In the paper, which is published in medical journal Acta Paediatrica, Sigman argues there has been a huge increase in children regularly using headphones, earphones (earbuds that go in the ear) and noise-cancelling headphones – and that this has ramifications for their education.

By age 12, most children are using headphones or earphones every day for at least one of music, TV, social media, gaming or online learning, Sigman says.

There are two issues with this rising use, he argues: increasing damage to children's ears from playing sound too loud in headphones, and potential developmental impacts of using noise-cancelling headphones in critical periods.

The risks of children using headphones

On the first of those, in 2022 the World Health Organisation said that more than risked losing their hearing because of prolonged and excessive loud noise exposure.

Hearing damage has massive consequences for children’s health and their education, Sigman says.

“You might pass a normal hearing test but have some damage to your hearing cells and ears, so that in a classroom you can’t perceive the teacher’s speech clearly because there’s other noise going on,â€� he tells ÌÇÐÄVlog.

“And when that happens, you have a cascade of educational problems.�

Even mild hearing loss in one ear increases a child’s chances of being placed in lower streams at secondary school, Sigman says.

There is also evidence that children attain lower grades in tests of maths, reading and writing with even mild hearing loss. This can happen through hearing loss causing issues with attention in the classroom, children facing cognitive fatigue due to having to expend greater mental energy to decode speech, and gaps in hearing causing delays in developing communication skills.

Children with hearing loss also experience changes in their brain with respect to how sounds are processed and, subsequently, how language develops, Sigman adds.

In addition, according to the NHS, of children may also experience tinnitus in some form.

And Sigman argues that noise-cancelling headphones may present their own adverse consequences.

“Blocking out everyday natural background noise during the critical development windows can prevent the brain from practising how to filter out sound,� he says.

“That’s important because brains need to know what to cut out, and what to attend to. In turn, this can affect speech comprehension and conversational abilities.�

Using noise-cancelling headphones too frequently could potentially cause a child’s brain to become dependent on quiet environments, and may hinder natural desensitisation to noises we should learn to become desensitised to.

“The real world has an acoustic landscape that [children] have to become familiar with, both for social reasons and academic reasons. And noise-cancelling headphones provide an unnatural environment where children don’t learn the necessary cues for the real world,� Sigman says.

What schools can do

So if excessive headphone use can have such consequences for children’s health, development and education, how can schools help?

There have not yet been many studies looking at the effects of noise-cancelling headphones and how to counteract these, given that widespread use is a relatively recent phenomenon.

But Sigman suggests that prevention is better than cure, explaining that “the general advice from the experts� is to limit headphone use during the day.

Public health advice tends to focus on excessive noise exposure rather than headphone use specifically, Sigman says. He argues there should be a detailed review of the impacts of headphone and earphone use on children’s development, which should be used to create national guidance for schools, parents and healthcare professionals.

Education on safe listening should also be a mandatory part of PSHE in schools, he recommends.

If children are using headphones for learning, schools should ideally provide them with over-the-ear headphones, rather than buds that go into the ear. Children’s ear canals are much shorter than adults’, and damage can happen far more easily with in-ear headphones, Sigman says.

“Headphones should also have a known volume limit,� he adds.

Above 75 decibels is where we start to see potential for hearing damage, he explains, but for children, who are more sensitive than adults, a good rule is that they should listen at no more than 60 per cent of the maximum volume, for no more than an hour at a time.

Breaks between listening sessions are also very important; these should last for 10 or 15 minutes at least.

“Even if [pupils are] listening to highly educational content, the hair cells in your inner ear, which are what turn sounds into signals that your brain reads, take a real beating from sustained louder sounds and they need a quiet stretch to recover,� Sigman says.

He adds: “If you don’t let them recover, they don’t come back.�

Noise-cancelling headphones do enable children to hear content while listening at a lower, safer volume, but their use “should have a clear purpose and not be unmonitored", Sigman says. "Blanket use is not acceptable.�

The amount of time students spend learning on laptops or tablets wearing headphones will vary from one setting to another, he says.

“Schools just need to be aware of this and ask how many hours children are spending in school where they have headphones on as part of their education, whether that is in a lesson or as part of some sort of revision, and how much time is spent having contact with their teacher and real-world awareness of the classroom and the pupils and activities going on there.�

Sigman’s argument refers to neurotypical children’s use of headphones, and he acknowledges that noise-cancelling headphones can be of particular use to children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND).

Teachers have reported a big rise in the number of pupils wearing ear defenders at school, and Sigman says there are risks associated with children becoming over-reliant on these.

In addition, some autistic children or pupils with ADHD have poor baseline auditory filtering or sensory processing issues, and Sigman warns that when using standard headphones, they may increase the headset to an extreme volume to compensate for background noise, and thus be at greater risk of hearing damage. Teachers will therefore need to monitor headphone use carefully.

Phones have now been banned from classrooms in the UK, and children under 16 will also be banned from social media from the spring.

Despite the lack of conclusive causative evidence of harm yet, for Sigman, this is the chance to consider whether we need to place limits on headphone use, too.

The sooner we recognise the issue, he argues, the more likely we will be able to protect children from the worst consequences of hearing damage.

To get essential briefings from ÌÇÐÄVlog magazine delivered directly to your inbox, sign up to our newsletters. And stay up to date with the latest education news via the ÌÇÐÄVlog magazine mobile app – available on and on

Share

Are noise-cancelling headphones harming learning?

/magazine/teaching-learning/general/are-noise-cancelling-headphones-harming-learning

topics in this article

Recent
Most read
Most shared