Get the best experience in our app
Enjoy offline reading, category favourites, and instant updates - right from your pocket.

Why flawed curriculum design needs substantial change

Teaching different courses in the same class risks damaging the mental health of staff andÌýstudents, says Andrew Bailey
31st January 2020, 5:02pm

Share

Why flawed curriculum design needs substantial change

/magazine/archive/why-flawed-curriculum-design-needs-substantial-change
'flawed Curriculum Design Needs Substantial Change'

Last week the Scottish Parliament’s Education and Skills Committee met to take further evidence from the Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) as part of their review into the senior phase and multi-qualificationÌýteaching.Ìý

Evidence given last year by the SQA and Education Scotland on multi-level teaching included this statement: “There is feedback from a range of engagements with teachers and young people thatÌýbi- and multi-level teaching may be challenging in aspects of some subjects…Education Scotland has yet to see any firm evidence from inspections of educational disadvantage due to multi-level teaching. The senior phase review will provide an opportunity to look into this issue.â€�

Is it an indictment of our education system that Education Scotland, a body whichÌýsupports learning and teaching and also inspects, does not have firm evidence in this respect?


Multi-course lessons:ÌýSQA admits pupils could be taught ‘same stuff’ twice

Last week:ÌýSQA exam body announces review of National 3 and 4

Quick read:Ìý‘A third of pupils feel the strain of schoolwork’


Multi-level teaching is not a new phenomenon. When I started teaching 15 years ago, my S4 physics pupils sat Standard Grade at General and Credit levels.Ìý Then, however,Ìýthere was better articulation betweenÌýlevels which allowed for blended learning.ÌýStandard Grade for me was true multi-level teaching, whereas allÌýother combinations since then are more accurately described as “multi-courseâ€�.

In , Dr Janet Brown, then the SQA chief executive, stated in regardÌýto National courses: “They were not designed along the lines of Standard Grade; they were designed as a progression route, either to National 5 or to college.â€�

Multi-level difficulties

At the time of the design of National 5, around 2012, a highly respected and experienced colleague within my authority was working with the SQA onÌýphysics specifications.Ìý I recall asking him how the specifications were being designed to articulate with National 4 to allow multi-level teaching within the same classroom.Ìý

His response, like Dr Brown’sÌýyears later, was that it was not.Ìý

It is my deeply held regret that this fundamental flaw was not corrected.ÌýThere was no doubt that in physics the Standard Grade course wasn’t perfect andÌýcertainly dated in terms of someÌýcontent - I have welcomed much of the new content in theÌýNationals - but teaching different abilitiesÌýin the same class has been made unnecessarily more challenging, more stressful for all, andÌýmuch harder to help get it right for each child.Ìý ÌýÌý

Multi-course teaching is not differentiation by outcome, but differentiation by task;Ìýthere is only a small overlap between the courses and, where commonalities occur - say between National 5 and Higher courses - the pace of learning and prior understanding is very different.Ìý Ìý

Teaching Intermediate 2 and Higher simultaneously,Ìýand now National 5 and Higher,Ìýled to high levels of stress and mental health issues for myself and someÌýstudents.ÌýIÌýdid everything I could to make it workÌýand made myself ill.Ìý It broke my heart to be unable to help one set of students who had embarked on a task because I was explaining or demonstrating a different concept to another set of pupils.

In 15Ìýyears of teaching I have only been absent for more than a few days twice - and both instances were due to accumulated stress caused by multi-course teaching for months on end. If Education Scotland has yet to see any firm evidence from inspections of educational disadvantage due to multi-course teaching, I would suggest that is entirely due to the hard work of teachers who make a poor situation work the best they can.Ìý I would also suggest they are talking to the wrong people, and that it is an indictment that teaching staff don’t feelÌýthey can have honest dialogue withÌýinspectorsÌýwithout consequences from their senior management.ÌýÌý

A colleague describes assessment of mixed-course classes as the “falling off the bus approachâ€�: everyone is National 5 until proved otherwise; when they fail, they are National 4; if they fail again after resits, they are National 3.ÌýThe difference in courses means the teacher rushes about to teach just enough of the parts of the course that are not in National 5 in sufficient depth to pass the assessments - this is not, in my opinion, a quality learning experience for those students.Ìý

Many in Scottish education - the government, SQA and unions -Ìýare advocating a period of constancy. However, I feel that the flaws of curriculum design are so substantial that change should be made now.Ìý

WhileÌýthere would be short-term pain due to yet more change, in the longer term courses that can be taught together successfully will reduce workload andÌýstress - and improve student learning and attainment for all.

Andrew Bailey is a science and physics teacher in Scotland. He is presenting workshops at ResearchEd Glasgow (1 February), an Association of Science Education Scotland conference (28ÌýMarch) and an Institute of Physics Stirling meeting (6 May).

Recent
Most read
Most shared